More on HPV vaccine criticisms, collaboration, and competition

As predicted, a slew of stories are appearing about HPV vaccines, with Gardasil's expected licensure later this week. A sampling of the best:

• Merck's $4 billion PR problem (Fortune) -- A look ahead at the (possible) battles that await Gardasil, particularly regarding opposition to state mandates. Includes quotes from Barbara Loe Fisher, perhaps the most prominent critic of vaccines, vaccine safety, and U.S. vaccination regulation and policy.

• Vaccine helps show value of partnerships (Boston Globe) -- Examines the collaboration between researchers at the National Cancer Institute, particularly Dr. Douglas Lowy, and subsequent commercial partners Merck and GSK in bringing HPV vaccines from the earliest stages of research through licensure. A great example of a successful public-private partnership, but one all but certain to add to the uneasiness of those who think the relationship between government and the pharmaceutical industry are too cozy.

• Cancer vaccine shows promise for older women (Reuters) -- Realizing the massive attention Merck's Gardasil will receive this month while its vaccine is months behind, GSK chose a conference this weekend to release new trial data on Cervarix. A 666-subject study of women age 15-55 showed that the vaccine generated antibody levels equal to those seen in younger women in earlier trials. What isn't answered in this or other stories is how beneficial it would be to launch HPV vaccination campaigns for older women, as many will have already been infected with the HPV types included in the vaccine.